Updated: December 20, 2016
Scent Strength (balance):
Col Conk shaving soaps are one of those products that I have a hard time speaking poorly about. Col Conk Almond soap was one of my first wet shaving soaps that I purchased, and as a result I think of it fondly (not sure if it is normal to feel fondly towards a shaving product but I do). Since then I have picked up a few more scents from the Colonel, the Lime, Amber, and the Bay Rum – which is the subject of this review.
As with all soaps I get excited about that first sniff of a freshly opened package. Unlike most soaps, Colonel Conk Bay Rum Shaving Soap did not overcome me with a terrific fragrance that had me thinking about my next shave for most of the day. In fact I had great difficulty detected any scent at all, if I was blindfolded I would have guessed fragrance free. Concerned that perhaps there was something wrong with my sense of smell I had my confirm that the scent was without a doubt lacking. I was more than disappointed. Sadly lathering the soap did very little to bring out any fragrance from the soap.
Happily the lather performed as I expected from a Col Conk soap. I was able to build a decent lather rather quick, provided a decent amount of cushion and a slick surface. That is not to say that Col Conks Bay Rum provided the greatest surface I have ever had from a shave soap, but for the cost, I feel it is what one would or should expect.
If you are on the fence as to whether or not to invest in a puck of Col Conk Bay Rum you need to ask yourself how important fragrance strength is vs. how much you wish to spend on a puck of soap. If you are looking for a Bay Rum soap that has a stronger scent you may want to turn your attention else where and consider something like one of the Ogallala Bay Rum Sweet Orange shave soap which offer a variety of Bay Rum fragrances.
Here is another opinion from Nick Shaves